Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Kicking Up Traditional Grilled Cheese with this AMAZING Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwich. I’m toasting thick slices of golden buttery Rosemary Olive Oil Artisan Bread and filling it with melted Provolone and Munster Cheese, Pesto, Fresh slices of juicy tomatoes, Spinach, Fresh Basil Leaves, and thin slices of Pepperoni. Served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.

Thick slices of toasted Rosemary Olive Oil Bread with Melted cheese, pepperoni, and tomatoes

Last weekend Mars and I took a little trip to my favorite Grocery Store. They have the MOST amazing bakery where beautiful Artisan breads, with their golden crispy crusts, beckon to me! (And… my carb loving soul runs towards them with great gusto! It’s like a love scene from a romantic movie! In S-L-O-W motion…cause even my soul doesn’t run! )

Any who…back to my story! I spied this gorgeous loaf of Rosemary Olive Oil Bread. It was truly stunning.

I knew instantly what I was going to cook up with that loaf of bread. The two of us (The bread and I..the love story) were going to take on the good ol’ American Grilled Cheese and create an Italian Grilled Cheese. A sandwich that would transport us to Rome! (Food can transport us…even to Rome! Cheap Air Fare!)

TIP: If you can’t find Rosemary Olive Oil Bread you can use an Artisan Asiago Bread or a really beautiful Country French Loaf. Both will work for this sandwich.

To create these delicious sandwiches you’ll need 1 loaf of Artisan Bread, Butter, Fresh Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Spinach Leaves, Provolone Cheese, Munster Cheese, prepared Basil Pesto, Deli Pepperoni, and your favorite Marinara sauce.

Ingredients for Italian Grilled Cheese

To being with…Butter the outside of each slice of Rosemary Olive Oil Bread. One the inside of one slice of bread spread Basil Pesto. (I’ve seriously been thinking about using this as a facial mask! lol Classico has nailed this pesto sauce.)

Slice of bread of Pesto spread on it.

On top of the pesto sauce, add two slices of Provolone Cheese, and 5-6 Large thin slices of Pepperoni.

Slice of break with pesto, layer of Provolone Cheese, and Pepperoni

Add a layer of thinly sliced fresh tomatoes, sprinkle with coarse black pepper.

Now…if you don’t like tomatoes you can leave them off. (Gasp!)

Italian Grilled Cheese Preparation with layer of fresh tomatoes

Guess what time it is? Yep! Time for another layer of cheese!

Add a layer of Munster Cheese.

Why Munster? Because it is creamy, yummy, and melts perfectly in grilled cheese. I’m of the opinion that ALL Grilled Cheese should contain Munster. Try it…you’ll thank me!

Next add a layer of Fresh Spinach Leaves and a few leaves of fresh basil. (Oh this sandwich is SOOOOO Good! SO GOOD! Drool worthy good!)

Building of Italian Grilled Cheese adding Munster Cheese, Spinach, and Fresh Basil

Place the top piece of butter bread, ummm… on top! Place sandwich on hot griddle. Over medium heat.

TIP: You don’t want the grill too hot or the bread will toast before the cheese melts. 

Grilled Italian Cheese ready to go on the grill.

When one side is golden brown…Flip the sandwiches over using two spatula’s.

You will need to contort your upper body while trying not to have the sandwich fly across the room! Good Luck with that! (I’m rooting’ for ya!)

While the sandwiches are toasting…heat individual cups of marinara sauce. I used Prego Traditional Spaghetti Sauce. You can use any brand you like.

Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches with melted cheese and golden bread.

This sandwich is loaded with so much flavor.

Please…PLEASE dip it in the marinara sauce while eating. You’ll thank me! It’s great on it’s own…but dunked in that warm marinara sauce…it’s OUTSTANDING! You could even serve them with a wonderful roasted tomato soup. Another Epic choice!

I’ve had two of these sandwiches this week. (There go all my secrets!) This Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwich has ruined me for regular grilled cheese! Truly!

Italian Grilled Cheese with Marinara Sauce.

This recipe will make 4 large Grilled Cheese!

It’s such a quick easy recipe and great for Lunch or Dinner. (I know…I had them for both…just to make sure!)

Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches with melted cheese and golden bread.

I L.O.V.E. this new recipe! It’s honestly one of my very favorites. I may have ruined myself for any other sandwiches out there! (Sorry Tuna, Turkey, and Ham! It was a good run while it lasted!)

Hope you love it as much as I do! Printable recipe is below. Have a GREAT Day!

I’m sharing this deliciousness at The Weekend Potluck and Meal Plan Monday! You can click on them to find all the YUM going on!

Happy Nesting!

Photo of Norine with her Signature and Tag Line

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
Norine Rogers

Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches make a fantastic lunch or dinner. Loaded with flavor they're one of the best sandwiches to pass your lips!


  • 8 slices of Rosemary Olive Oil Artisan Bread or Asiago Artisan Bread
  • Butter, Softened
  • 8 slices of Provolone Cheese
  • 8 slices of Munster Cheese
  • 20 slices of large thinly sliced pepperoni
  • 2 large tomatoes, thinly sliced
  • 20-30 leaves of fresh spinach leaves, washed and dried
  • 1 bunch of fresh basil leaves
  • Prepared Basil Pesto
  • 1 jar marinara sauce
  • Coarse black pepper, to taste

  1. Preheat griddle over medium heat.
  2. Butter one side of each slice of bread
  3. On the inside of four slices of bread, spread Pesto Sauce, about 1 Tablespoon.
  4. Place two slices of Provolone Cheese on top of each slice of bread with pesto.
  5. Add 5-6 slices of thin pepperoni to each sandwich. Top with 2-3 slices of tomato. Sprinkle with coarse black pepper.
  6. Top each sandwich with two slices of Munster cheese. Add Spinach leaves and a thin layer of fresh basil.
  7. Top with other slice of bread.
  8. Place sandwich butter side down on hot griddle. Grill till bread is golden brown and cheese is melting. Flip sandwich over and toast till done.
  9. While sandwich is grilling fill small cups with marinara sauce and warm in microwave.

Prep Time: 10 minutes - Cook Time: 15 minutes ; Yield: 4 sandwiches
Serving Size: 1 sandwich
https://www.norinesnest.com/italian-grilled-cheese-sandwiches/

3 COMMENTS

  1. Jane | 21st Apr 18

    Hey Norine!
    I’m writing the ingredients for this recipe in my trusty grocery list phone App right now. Can’t wait to make it! My 24 year old (pepperoni pizza hound) will love it! I’m one of those people who have never tried Munster in a Grilled Cheese Sandwich. I always love trying something new! 🙂 Have a great weekend!

  2. Amy | 13th May 18

    Oh my, these sandwiches look so good. What a great combination of ingredients. Your picture of the sandwich is amazing. Keep up the good work in your emptier nest; mine is getting that way too.

    • norine@norinesnest.com | 14th May 18

      Hi Amy!
      Thank you so much for your sweet compliments. Ya made my day. I hope you had a great Mother’s Day! Thanks for stopping by.
      Happy Nesting…or almost Empty Nesting 😉
      Norine

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *